Grades for Backbreaker and the assumption of what Madden 11 will be on their respective curves: Backbreaker- A+ Madden 11-B-
Backbreaker is an A+ due to it's first year out, NEVER lying to the customer, football NOT being put into compartments but a full gameplay based on physics which SHOULD be the core of any SIMULATION football video game
also Backbreaker is WAY more open to their consumers (hopefully if they ever get bigger they won't shutdown the responsiveness and caring they show their community), Backbreaker understands football principles and the possibilities of how INCREDIBLY AWESOME, FUN, and SWEET SIMULATION their game can be is just limitless giving it an A+ with no major drawbacks and a MUST buy for all simulation football fans
Madden 11 receives a B- minus barely staying in the Bs due to marketing and the known name and improving every year but deceiving their customers, buying out the competition to be lazy and dominant, and generally giving their customers recycled features and calling them new
Madden 11 will be an improvement as they feel the heat of the Supreme Court decisions, Backbreaker and 2k fans, their own customers and sells dropped, they got good feedback from their community and will be implementing what they were asked to do (even though it's always way too limited especially based off their sales, customer support, and capabilities), possible lockout for the NFL and licensing agreement running out (make as much money as possible with the NFL while we can)
Madden 11 is VERY in depth as far as features but implementation and the actual fun and realism they bring is always questioned-prime examples: ratings, Madden arcade, Madden cards revitalized in a new form lol, making us pay for once free things- how much fun is that and where is the business ethics involved?
sounds like Madden 11 will be another INCREDIBLY AWESOME edition to all the glitchers, cheaters, cheese players, unknowledgeable concerning football using 1 play successfully all game, and generally the arrogant and disrespectful players I've come across who/
all who have bought Madden year after year KNOW Madden 11 will not leaps and bounds better than Madden 10 nor do many think that's a fair expectation with football still being pretty much the same lol and only feeling only so much improvement is humanly possible
my issue with that is yes there is only so much a people can do with a video game but Backbreaker has helped me see the light and if Madden cannot gameplay wise eradicate for the most part the glitches, cheese, and cheats and make actual football strategy mean WAY more than it has meant than they have only improved aesthetically and have not addressed the major REAL issues plaguing their brand
again I've loved Madden the game and the announcer John Madden forever basically but John Madden doesn't make the game and EA has definitely deceived it's customers because they are either unwilling or unable to produce the kind of game they can and should have been done
again EA always promises so much and brings tragic flaws galore to the table but still sells due to unjust hype, mercy, hope, and marketing
Point: I feel EA's ideas are for the most part TOP NOTCH but their implementation of them are less then acceptable with the kind of MONEY they receive from their customers
If Backbreaker took it's physics and seriousness along with care for the consumer and joined forces with Madden's ideas, popularity/marketing, and in depth ratings and modes the game we've been looking for could be out in 2-5 years (if we were extremely blessed next year LOL)
I'm just saying both games have their positives but Madden in my humble opinion is NOT as good as Backbreaker because Backbreaker's gameplay is miles ahead of Madden
Gameplay aka how a game plays when you play it is the most important part of any game. That's why Backbreaker is better than Madden.