I have multiple profiles set for each offensive scheme I use. I have the same default defensive, so I name my profiles after each offensive playbook.
***THIS DOES NOT REQUIRE MULTIPLE PLAYSTATION NETWORK ACCOUNTS***
I'm not sure if everyone knows this, but you are able to save multiple profiles. On each profile, it will save your playbooks and audibles. You will need to go to settings to turn off auto-strafe/auto-sprint. If you have favorite uniforms saved, you'll have to go save those, but you'll still be able to use your "ROSTER-CUSTOM"; aka the one you save your depth chart on.
This is how you do it.
Step 1: Create a new profile
Go to My Madden > File Management > Save
The word "Profile" will be highlighted when you click on the Save option, now you'll see on the right "New profile with default settings.."
Click "New profile with default settings.."
Now type in the new name for the new scheme you want to use then press start to save it. I keep the same defense, but have multiple offenses. I name my profiles after my offense.
Step 2: Fix your settings
Go to My Madden > Settings > Game Options
Put in your favorite team / playbooks / etc.
Don't forget to change coaching tips OFF, strategy pad quick links ON, coordinator audio OFF, coordinator subtitles OFF, Auto-Strafe OFF, Auto-Sprint OFF, and Game Speed NORMAL. (These are just my settings that I use. I think most people have these exact settings. I put normal for game speed because that's the game speed for online play.)
Do not forget to put player skill to All-Pro or All-Madden. Default is on Pro. (This is just if you wanna play offline.)
Step 3: Audibles
Go to My Madden > Coaching Options > Offensive/Defensive Audibles
Set your audibles.
After you have set your audibles, press L3 to Save everything.
Step 4: How to access each profile [If you go to Change Active Profile, none of your other profile will show up; this is the correct way to access your other profiles.]
Go to My Madden > File Management > Load - Delete
Now "Profile" will be highlighted. Select the profile on the right that is the new scheme you want to use..