Vick Best Qb ?

Is vick the best qb in the league right now, discuss.

In my eyes yes.

I feel he is the best right now as well...duel threat...he can run and he is showing accuracy in the pocket. hands down!

ya the performance last night was honestly the best I have ever seen.

his performance was disgusting, 99 overall in madden for that.

comback player of the history of nfl

He should be the mvp but the nfl is corrupt and he wont win it watch...

Not at all.

#1 dont listen to the media- thats been the discussion in the news since last nights game

#2 dont fall victim to the "last you remember"

1. Manning/Brady
2. Drew Brees
3. Aaron Rodgers
4. Philip Rivers
5. I'll take arguments for Vick to be here

sgibs wrote:

Not at all.

#1 dont listen to the media- thats been the discussion in the news since last nights game

#2 dont fall victim to the "last you remember"

1. Manning/Brady
2. Drew Brees
3. Aaron Rodgers
4. Philip Rivers
5. I'll take arguments for Vick to be here

oh i thought we were just talkin about based off of his performance last night.

Saying which QB is the best in the league is all opinion...of course there are guys playing great football...Its all about which style of QB you like more...

Im talking about right now showing noones past or no ones play off record vick is definately the best no ?'s asked manning's not because he doesn't have any wr's (there all hurt) thats the only one who i could see even being a argument.

^ doesn't really make much sense to me to be honest.

Peyton Hillis is the best HB in the league one week ago.


Just the kinda scenario that we are trying to play here.

Vick is good and hes playing well. However to compare him and think hes a better Quarterback then 2 of the greatest to everplay the game. Silly.

Vick is definitely up there as far as this season goes...

Brees? No, this guy has already cost his team a game--4 picks against the Browns.
Manning? Yes, guy throws for 400 yards and 4 tds in a loss.
Brady? Yes, see Sunday Night Football.
Rivers? Maybe, playing great but can't seem get it done in the clutch (Chiefs).
Rodgers? Yes, he just wins.

very fair breakdown

Rivers is doing more with less then I have ever seen i think lol. Who are these guyssss! Howevre you are right hes just not winning.

Why not talk about Matt Cassels performance as being one of the best this season if we are going to give vick the title? he had a d@mn good game last week!@

I agree with beotos im talking about this season , no one has yet to "contain" him.

I think i just edited your post? lol

i ment to quote it

Vick has the highest qb rating I dont see where your going with this hes thrown NO interceptions. when it comes playoff time yes he WILL choke and the greats will shine but as of now he is the best.

if you look at stats as your only determining factor of who the best QB in the NFL is...then you win the argument.

if you weigh other things Vick is not the best QB. Again dont focus so heavily on the most recent thing you have seen.

best? no

Top 10. maybe


lets see if he can consistantly do that, b4 we start having best talks

Gibs how about an Eagles scheme from the MAD DEN

I under stand totally but no one has proven they can stop him. your right no one can really stop manning, brady, or brees but he such a dual threat running and passing and its so hard to make a game plan for him. You following me now?

Understand the performance last night was against a defense that gives up over 400 to 450+ yards in a lot of their games this year. He will not do that against a top 5 defense.


Knowing EA Vick will only be an 89 after this week because the ratings are still whack.



Thanks,



haseo15

Vick this season is the best QB numbers wise
62.7 Comp %
1,350 Yards
225.0 YPG
11 passing TD
0 INT
115.1 QB RATING best in the nfl
plus 341 yards rushing 7.8 per attempt and 4tds

VICK has ment the most to his team this season and with a win next week I believe the eagles are the best team in the NFL.

gunfused-

Vick has been tough to scheme against since he came into the league. In terms of a QB though he just doesnt get it done with his passing.

hes showing thats he improved greatly this year but lets not forget hes played in 5 of the 9 games?

Vick has a long way to go to be considered the best in the leauge

He is definitley not the best in the league. LOL @ that. For the eagles being the best in the nfl, lol @ that too.

ONe good game and this is what you hear now. Jesus.

only thing that really matters is that he looked good on sunday

he looked unreal on sunday- one of the best performance I have ever seen by a QB.

In my mind the best performance I can remember is the Pats Titans Snowbowl! last season! Brady was unreal that game slinging the magic bean around