Brady vs. Manning

UndefeatedIV wrote:

personally i believe manning is a better quarterback for the simple fact that Brady is a systematic quarterback, which was proven when he sat out one year and Cassel led them to a winning season, Now cassel is playing like a second rate qb which shows you that a system can make a qb look spectacular, im not saying brady cant make those tight throws, but as far as accuracy, smarts, and overall ability give me manning any day.

Its amazing how much yall stay in mannings butt. Matt Cassell did ok for us but he couldn't do anything against the big boys like the Steelers, Chargers and a few others and it cost us a playoff spot, Tom carves those teams up for the record. Don't ever compare a 1st ballot Hall of famer with average player u must be sick in ur azz. The Patriots won games because Bill is always gonna atleast try and be ready for any situation and he won't let his team curl up in the fetal position and cry about there star qb being hurt.

dahulkoliver wrote:

something else a lot of you are missing is most of manning interceptions are off of dropped or tipped passes off of his own receivers hands so a lot of pics that manning throws aren't even his fault. Brady on the other hand doesn't have that happen

U must don't watch football, was that manning fault in the superbowl when he got picked for the game sealing td no that wasn't his fault. Mannings so good he only has 1 championship lets not forget that.

xHEx DeathAngel wrote:

Thats nice and all, but does everyone see what the colts are doing. The Pats are built have success with any Qb, where as the colts are only built right now to have success with Peyton Manning.



Thanks,


haseo15

I don't care what anyone says no one player makes that big a difference yeah he maybe able to make a few more throws, but it takes all 11 on offense to be successful. Montana got hurt a few times as well that didn't stop Bill Walsh from being ready for situation he went a got Steve Young. Oh yeah they're system qbs to so they're not that good either, even though they're in the HOF.

the game i diasgree with you manning is the better qb hands down yes he doesnt have as many rings as brady but he also didnt have the system brady does. put manning in that system and he has more rings than brady

Wolfman wrote:

the game i diasgree with you manning is the better qb hands down yes he doesnt have as many rings as brady but he also didnt have the system brady does. put manning in that system and he has more rings than brady

Why do yall keep saying the system the system the system, the greatest system in the world for a qb is the west coast offense and the best qb of all time ran it with one of the greatest coaches of all time Joe Montana and Bill Walsh. Yet I've never heard anyone call Joey a system qb, thats my beef, I can careless what u guys think u know about the position of quarterbacking. Most of u go by what the commentators say or some throws u may see. Quarterbacking is about footwork, seeing the field, reading defenses, leadership, being able to make all the throws, command of the offense, footwork under pressure (manning really lacks in this area). I know for sure Tom is hands down the better qb of the 2. Manning has all the numbers why? He's had better talent at the skill positions then the Pats, they also threw the ball more. We just started throwing the ball as much if not more starting in 07 with Moss and Welker in company. With that talent Tom has surpassed Manning in that same time frame for the guys who worry about stats.

footwork under pressure manning lacks? dude i hate most of the commentators. yes brady is a good qb but he is not better than manning. ill take manning over brady any day of the week hands down

Wolfman wrote:

the game i diasgree with you manning is the better qb hands down yes he doesnt have as many rings as brady but he also didnt have the system brady does. put manning in that system and he has more rings than brady

brady has not had anywere near the weapons manning has had, harrison, edge, clark,wayne,garcon , so i don't understand when you say the system brady was in? who deion branch and a bunch of other WRs that we can't remember there names now....or was it the system of kevin faulk and corey dillon? LOL

brady barely has a run game year in and year out, and as far as clutch factor brady >manning

to be real Indy let a few what should have been super bowl appearances slip away due to manning's clutch and the defense

for you to say manning better hands down is

look at where the colts r without manning... and u dont need big names to be a threat yes the patriots proved that. but u saying brady barely having a run game, when under manning have the colts ever had a consistent run game

Wolfman wrote:

look at where the colts r without manning... and u dont need big names to be a threat yes the patriots proved that. but u saying brady barely having a run game, when under manning have the colts ever had a consistent run game

the colts sucked last year with manning, the team as a whole started its decline last year ..........

the colts have had multiple 1,000 yard backs i know edge and addai both have eclipsed that, so the colts have had some more rushing success

Simply put wolfman Brady has done more with less (as far as team success) so Brady > Manning

either way they are 2 great qbs

Manning also made the Super Bowl a coupe of years ago with the 32nd or 31 running attack and an average defense. He has not had a 1,000 yard rusher since addai's second season i think, which is a while back.


I'll take manning any day of the week over brady.



Thanks,


haseo15

Manning because he simply is a student of the game. Brady had always had a great team around him. I am not saying that Manning did not, but he just studies the game in his sleep.

yeah both great QBs, and when someone says manning is a student of the game? And Brady isn't?? you don't get to an elite level without putting your work in, every pats coach and player will tell you Bradys first 3-4 seasons in the league he stayed later than everyone else at the practice facility and was the first one there everyday, most people thought he was sleeping at the facilitys....

Also Brady is much more clutch than manning

I don't get were Brady's teams have had way better players than manning's team?? Maybe a few better defensive players at LB, but other than that the talent level on both teams is and or has been close to even

both are great and in my eyes thats all that matters